List rental 101: 12 FAQs on cold data for direct mail campaigns – answered
So you’re considering testing cold direct mail but wondering how to find the mailing lists you need to reach your target audiences, and then to ensure that the data is also compliant and usable? Read on as we answer 12 of the questions we hear most often.
1. With all the GDPR requirements, is it really worth it?
Absolutely. Cold direct mail gets noticed – by all age groups, it can be closely targeted and tracked, and it’s driving record levels of digital engagement. It does involve more paperwork than it did 10 years ago but most of the hard work is done for the first campaign. After that it just needs revisiting annually, or if something changes. Your data use is your responsibility, so you need to do the due diligence to understand what you’re doing, the basis on which you’re contacting people, and whether the data is compliant. But a professional data adviser such as your list broker can guide you through the process, and it’s well worth the effort for the opportunity of reaching new donors and building your supporter base.
2. How many people can we reach, & how many lists are available for cold direct mail?
The short answer is that there are millions of individuals in consented and compliant records, held across 40–50 different lists in the UK. These include lifestyle, mail order and consumer survey data, as well as the Electoral Roll open register. While it won’t all be relevant for charity use, or meet your specific audience demographic, there is more than enough data for almost any charity to test cold direct mail to see if it works for your cause and message, and to then roll out further mailings with confidence.
3. How recent is the data on these lists?
It depends on where the data originates but some mail order lists are very dynamic so the data can be extremely current. Generally, you’ll want data with a 0–12-month recency. Normally 0–6-month recency will perform better than 7–12-month data. However, recency isn’t always king. If a list is used a lot, you might be better off taking the slightly older data. This won’t have been mailed quite so frequently, so it’s likely to be more responsive as a result.
4. There’s an overwhelming number of data suppliers out there – are they all providing the same data?
Some lists are an amalgamation of sources so there is inevitably some overlap, but each data owner will have a unique take on a name because of how and why it was collected. This means suppliers aren’t offering the same data, even if some names appear on multiple lists. In fact, you don’t really want unique names – someone whose details appear on more than one list will be used to receiving direct mail and therefore more likely to respond.
5. Should we be working with a list manager or broker to source what we need?
This really depends on your requirements. If you know what you want and are confident about which questions to ask to ensure the data is not only responsive and compliant but will match the profile you are looking for, you can go to a list manager directly. If you’re not sure what you need, want help defining your target audience for greatest propensity, or you require a mix of lists, talk to a list broker. Brokers tend to be independent and as such have a wider view of what’s available on the market and how those lists perform. They’ll also ask all those key questions as a matter of course, working with you to find the right match for your campaign needs.
6. Can we source lists that we can use as they are, or do they always require segmentation work?
Lifestyle and the open electoral roll datasets are the only lists you can really segment, because they tend to be large and hold a broad range of information about the individual. The bigger the dataset, the more selections you can apply to find a mailable volume of the people you want to talk to. In contrast, the information in a mail order list is more limited so there is less to segment. You can also source more niche lists that may fit your audience profile as they stand, so you only need to worry about data recency. Your choice will be guided by who you want to reach, how many names you want to mail, and the type of organisation you are.
7. We want a bespoke list – how do we go about that?
A broker can source a variety of lists, then merge and dedupe them to create a bespoke volume. It’s also possible to source names that aren’t already on the market, but this is expensive, reaching up to £30 a name. Building a list from scratch isn’t unusual in the business world where you might be selling a product for £50,000, but less common in the charity world. Here, it’s most likely to be considered when seeking legators or major donors.
8. How do we check a list’s quality and compliance?
The quickest way is to ask the provider to fill in a DMA (Direct Marketing Association) third-party due diligence questionnaire or one they've produced themselves. This will tell you how the data is generated, how it is cleaned, and whether they’ve had any complaints. You’ll also need to find the original source of that data and check its privacy policy. A broker will automatically handle this for you as a matter of course.
9. Do we have to do any data cleansing / suppression ourselves?
Yes, you should always dedupe and clean your active data against suppression files before you use it to ensure your campaign is compliant and not inadvertently mailing people who are already on your own database, deceased records, goneaways or people who have opted out from being contacted. It will also save you money and help protect your charity’s reputation.
10. Is there an optimum volume for a decent return?
No, but there's an optimum volume for a statistically valid response. You need to balance how many you mail against your anticipated response rate. Charities sometimes want to dip a toe in the water with 5,000-10,000 records but at that level you’re unlikely to get sufficient response to know if what you’re testing really works or not. I would advise mailing between 25,000 and 30,000 records for a test.
However, if you're just starting out, my strongest recommendation is not to read any results at list level. There's so much to get right first, such as your creative and your proposition, before you begin to consider individual datasets.
11. What can we expect to pay?
I normally allow anything from £150 to £200 per 1,000 names, and in your calculations remember that is plus VAT.
12. How does the data arrive, and how quickly can we get it?
Data is delivered electronically via SFTP (Secure File Transfer Protocol). If you’re a first-time user, allow five to ten working days from placing the order. What usually takes the time is getting all the necessary paperwork in place, and subsequent data delivery times tend to be much faster.
Cold direct mail is a great channel for engaging new audiences with your cause and inspiring people to become supporters. If you’re thinking about taking that first step with a test campaign, and would like some help or advice, get in touch!